![]() |
What I found particularly interesting was a footnote in the original paper. Clance and Imes questioned whether men experienced the impostor phenomenon at all. Their clinical experience suggested that it occurred much less frequently in men and, when it did, with considerably less intensity. They even suggested that the men who experienced it were more in touch with their “feminine” qualities.
That was 1978, and I think it's fair to say our understanding has moved on somewhat in the nearly fifty years since. We now know that men experience impostor syndrome too, and that it isn't necessarily any less intense. It isn't exclusively a female phenomenon, nor is it a sign of femininity. It's something that can affect anyone, regardless of gender, experience or achievement.
Interestingly, a 2024 meta-analysis involving over 40,000 participants found that women still reported slightly higher levels of impostor feelings than men, although the difference was relatively small (Cohen's d = 0.27). So there may still be a gender difference, but it's certainly not as clear-cut as the original researchers suspected. ()
I don't think this takes anything away from the original research. Quite the opposite. Clance and Imes were describing something they had observed, and they explicitly acknowledged that their observations about men needed further research. That's how research is supposed to work. We learn something, investigate it, challenge it and refine our understanding. Sometimes we discover that what we thought we knew wasn't quite right.

"The authors suggested that childhood experiences, family expectations and societal gender stereotypes contributed..." I suggest that men tend to exhibit their imposter syndrome differently because of such things.
ReplyDelete